American Home Shield Review

American Home Shield is one of the best Home Warranty Companies in the nation due to their highly customizable plans…
We recommend products and services based on unbiased research from our editorial team. We may receive compensation if you click on a link.

You Might Also Like:

  • Choice Home Warranty
  • Cinch

American Home Shield is a great choice if you’re searching for a home warranty, which covers some repairs to appliances and systems in your home. A range of flexible plans and a large network of repair technicians increase the odds that the repair you need will be covered by your contract — and completed in a timely manner. 

 A major benefit to American Home Shield is their highly customizable policies, as well as the company’s longevity – leading to over 2 million customers receiving more than $2 billion paid in warranty claims over the last five years. Homeowners can certainly trust American Home Shield to protect the appliances and various home systems that we all depend on.

Overview of American Home Shield Services:

Plans Available: Appliances, Home Systems, Build Your Own Plans and other Combo options

Pricing: Varies by location and plan type but general monthly costs range between $39.99 – $59.99

Length of Contracts: 1 Year is standard 

National Coverage: 49 States

Service Fees: $75 – $125 

Other Benefits:

  • 30-Day Guarantee 
  • No Home Inspection required

Features: What kind of Services does American Home Shield offer?

 

Customizable coverage

American Home Shield offers four plans — a Systems plan, an Appliance Plan, a Combo plan, and a Build Your Own plan. Over the phone, representatives will work with you to customize your policy during the quote process. For instance, one of our testers’ homes didn’t have air conditioning, so the rep removed that from coverage to lower her rate. When speaking with reps via online chat and phone, we found them polite and helpful across the board.

No home inspection required

Unlike many providers, AHS does not require home inspections before signing off on your warranty. Some providers use these inspections as a chance to omit older appliances from your contract (read: things more likely to break).

Choose your service fee

When you set up your plan, you have the ability to choose a service call fee of $75, $100, or $125. This is the one-off cost you’ll need to pay, along with a small convenience fee, if you need to request a service tech. Higher service fees will lower your monthly premium: Testers who chose a $100 service call fee saved $9 per month over the lower $75 fee. If you have relatively new appliances and aren’t expecting multiple catastrophes to strike per year, we’d suggest opting for a higher service fee.

How To Get Started:

 

You have four options to choose from when you sign up: Start by going to the American Home Shield website and receive a fast and easy Free Quote in minutes.

The Appliances Plan (your water heater), the Systems Plan (your plumbing system), the Combo Plan (a combination of the Appliances and Systems plans), or the Build Your Own Plan(which allows you to select the items you want covered yourself). You also have the option to backdate coverage to the date you purchased your home, depending on how soon after you apply for American Home Shield coverage. This level of customization is unusual within the industry and allows you to pay for only the coverage you need.

It’s important to note that the home warranty industry as a whole suffers from extremely low customer satisfaction. This dissatisfaction often stems from vague contracts, denied repairs, and disagreements over the quality of repairs that are completed. We found that American Home Shield does a better job than other major providers at keeping fine print to a minimum, but it’s still important to read your contract carefully before signing. American Home Shield continues receiving great reviews and testimonials from their existing customers

Check Out This Year's Best Home Warranty Companies!

How to Get the Best Service: Things to consider

 

For an AHS home warranty to provide you the peace of mind and financial benefits it promises, there are three things you need to do:

  • Choose coverage that you actually need. The option to build a plan is unusual within the industry, and it ensures that you’re not paying for a package that includes coverage for things you might not want or need. Because of this flexibility, the odds are much better that your AHS policy will cover the things you actually want covered.
  • Don’t do anything that will nullify your policy. Home warranties, including those from AHS, take certain decisions away from the consumer. Calling in your own repair guy (even just for an inspection), attempting to do maintenance yourself, or jerry-rigging an appliance for a different use will negate coverage. Failing to perform maintenance as specified by your appliance’s user manual or manufacturer can also negate coverage.
  • Understand what’s excluded. American Home Shield’s contracts are more clear and generous than most, but all home warranty contracts come with serious caveats when it comes to when your warranty can be applied. An example: Your plumbing system might be covered, but this usually doesn’t include bathtubs, sinks, or showers.

The Final Call: 

 

Only you can decide if an American Home Shield warranty makes sense for your home. Due to the highly customizable options for their coverage and plans, they continue to be one of our Best Picks for Home Warranty Companies this year. Consider the age and value of your home systems and appliances, do the math to figure out how much you’d be set back if some of your larger items failed, and measure if the potential savings are worth the exchange of freedoms and limitations that come with any home warranty. Then spend some time quote-surfing. AHS is a strong contender based on its customizable plans and helpful customer service, but getting quotes from multiple companies ensures that you’re getting the cheapest premium for the coverage you need.

Check out other Best Home Warranty Companies Here

American Home Shield FAQ’s:

Does American Home Shield cover electrical systems?

American Home Shield home warranties offer coverage for major components of many home systems, including your electrical system in most cases. So American Home Shield can cover the electrical systems in your home.

Is American Home Shield worth it?

Home Warranty Companies often times come under attack for not being worth the investment. American Home Shield has a good reputation from their existing customers though so they can be trusted.

Does American Home Shield have a waiting period?

When you buy a home warranty policy with American Home Shield, there is a 30-day waiting period before you get started. This waiting period includes when you can make service requests and use your home warranty plan to protect your current appliances and home systems.

Does American Home Shield cover pre-existing conditions?

American Home Shield does cover certain pre-existing conditions, as long as the conditions were previously undetectable. This means that the conditions could not be identified by visual inspection for faulty parts or from a mechanical test that includes turning the device on and off to determine if it actually works properly.